Malus: improvements in dispute ancestor and suggest garbage candidate implementation (#5011)

* Implement fake validation results

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* refactor

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* cargo lock

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* spell check

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* spellcheck

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* typos

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* Review feedback

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* move stuff around

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* chores

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* Impl valid - still wip

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* fixes

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* fmt

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* Pull Ladi's implementation:
https://github.com/paritytech/polkadot/pull/4711

Co-authored-by: Lldenaurois <Ljdenaurois@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>
Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* Fix build

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* Logs and comments

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* WIP: suggest garbage candidate + implement validation result caching

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* fix

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* Do commitment hash checks in candidate validation

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* Minor refactor in approval, backing, dispute-coord

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* Working version of suggest garbage candidate

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* Dedup

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* cleanup #1

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* Fix tests

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* remove debug leftovers

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* fmt

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* Accidentally commited some local test

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* spellcheck

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* some more fixes

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* Refactor and fix it

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* review feedback

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* typo

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* tests review feedback

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* refactor disputer

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* fix tests

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* Fix zombienet disputes test

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* spellcheck

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* fix

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* Fix ui tests

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

* fix typo

Signed-off-by: Andrei Sandu <andrei-mihail@parity.io>

Co-authored-by: Lldenaurois <Ljdenaurois@gmail.com>

polkadot/Cargo.lock

@@ -7608,6 +7608,7 @@ dependencies = [
  "futures-timer",
  "parity-util-mem",
  "polkadot-cli",
+ "polkadot-erasure-coding",
  "polkadot-node-core-backing",
  "polkadot-node-core-candidate-validation",
  "polkadot-node-core-dispute-coordinator",

polkadot/cli/src/cli.rs

@@ -81,6 +81,7 @@ pub struct ValidationWorkerCommand {
 
 #[allow(missing_docs)]
 #[derive(Debug, Parser)]
+#[cfg_attr(feature = "malus", derive(Clone))]
 pub struct RunCmd {
 	#[allow(missing_docs)]
 	#[clap(flatten)]

polkadot/node/core/approval-voting/src/lib.rs

@@ -2273,7 +2273,7 @@ async fn launch_approval(
 				CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromExhaustive(
 					available_data.validation_data,
 					validation_code,
-					candidate.descriptor.clone(),
+					candidate.clone(),
 					available_data.pov,
 					APPROVAL_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT,
 					val_tx,

polkadot/node/core/backing/src/lib.rs

@@ -31,8 +31,8 @@ use futures::{
 };
 
 use polkadot_node_primitives::{
-	AvailableData, PoV, SignedDisputeStatement, SignedFullStatement, Statement, ValidationResult,
+	AvailableData, InvalidCandidate, PoV, SignedDisputeStatement, SignedFullStatement, Statement,
-	BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT,
+	ValidationResult, BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT,
 };
 use polkadot_node_subsystem_util::{
 	self as util,
@@ -41,8 +41,8 @@ use polkadot_node_subsystem_util::{
 	request_validators, FromJobCommand, JobSender, Validator,
 };
 use polkadot_primitives::v2::{
-	BackedCandidate, CandidateCommitments, CandidateDescriptor, CandidateHash, CandidateReceipt,
+	BackedCandidate, CandidateCommitments, CandidateHash, CandidateReceipt, CollatorId,
-	CollatorId, CommittedCandidateReceipt, CoreIndex, CoreState, Hash, Id as ParaId, SessionIndex,
+	CommittedCandidateReceipt, CoreIndex, CoreState, Hash, Id as ParaId, SessionIndex,
 	SigningContext, ValidatorId, ValidatorIndex, ValidatorSignature, ValidityAttestation,
 };
 use polkadot_subsystem::{
@@ -378,14 +378,14 @@ async fn request_pov(
 
 async fn request_candidate_validation(
 	sender: &mut JobSender<impl SubsystemSender>,
-	candidate: CandidateDescriptor,
+	candidate_receipt: CandidateReceipt,
 	pov: Arc<PoV>,
 ) -> Result<ValidationResult, Error> {
 	let (tx, rx) = oneshot::channel();
 
 	sender
 		.send_message(CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromChainState(
-			candidate,
+			candidate_receipt,
 			pov,
 			BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT,
 			tx,
@@ -456,11 +456,9 @@ async fn validate_and_make_available(
 				.with_pov(&pov)
 				.with_para_id(candidate.descriptor().para_id)
 		});
-		request_candidate_validation(&mut sender, candidate.descriptor.clone(), pov.clone()).await?
+		request_candidate_validation(&mut sender, candidate.clone(), pov.clone()).await?
 	};
 
-	let expected_commitments_hash = candidate.commitments_hash;
-
 	let res = match v {
 		ValidationResult::Valid(commitments, validation_data) => {
 			gum::debug!(
@@ -469,16 +467,6 @@ async fn validate_and_make_available(
 				"Validation successful",
 			);
 
-			// If validation produces a new set of commitments, we vote the candidate as invalid.
-			if commitments.hash() != expected_commitments_hash {
-				gum::debug!(
-					target: LOG_TARGET,
-					candidate_hash = ?candidate.hash(),
-					actual_commitments = ?commitments,
-					"Commitments obtained with validation don't match the announced by the candidate receipt",
-				);
-				Err(candidate)
-			} else {
 			let erasure_valid = make_pov_available(
 				&mut sender,
 				n_validators,
@@ -502,7 +490,15 @@ async fn validate_and_make_available(
 					Err(candidate)
 				},
 			}
-			}
+		},
+		ValidationResult::Invalid(InvalidCandidate::CommitmentsHashMismatch) => {
+			// If validation produces a new set of commitments, we vote the candidate as invalid.
+			gum::warn!(
+				target: LOG_TARGET,
+				candidate_hash = ?candidate.hash(),
+				"Validation yielded different commitments",
+			);
+			Err(candidate)
 		},
 		ValidationResult::Invalid(reason) => {
 			gum::debug!(

polkadot/node/core/backing/src/tests.rs

@@ -24,7 +24,8 @@ use futures::{future, Future};
 use polkadot_node_primitives::{BlockData, InvalidCandidate};
 use polkadot_node_subsystem_test_helpers as test_helpers;
 use polkadot_primitives::v2::{
-	CollatorId, GroupRotationInfo, HeadData, PersistedValidationData, ScheduledCore,
+	CandidateDescriptor, CollatorId, GroupRotationInfo, HeadData, PersistedValidationData,
+	ScheduledCore,
 };
 use polkadot_subsystem::{
 	messages::{
@@ -332,12 +333,12 @@ fn backing_second_works() {
 			virtual_overseer.recv().await,
 			AllMessages::CandidateValidation(
 				CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromChainState(
-					c,
+					candidate_receipt,
 					pov,
 					timeout,
 					tx,
 				)
-			) if pov == pov && &c == candidate.descriptor() && timeout == BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT => {
+			) if pov == pov && &candidate_receipt.descriptor == candidate.descriptor() && timeout == BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT &&  candidate.commitments.hash() == candidate_receipt.commitments_hash => {
 				tx.send(Ok(
 					ValidationResult::Valid(CandidateCommitments {
 						head_data: expected_head_data.clone(),
@@ -419,6 +420,8 @@ fn backing_works() {
 		.build();
 
 		let candidate_a_hash = candidate_a.hash();
+		let candidate_a_commitments_hash = candidate_a.commitments.hash();
+
 		let public1 = CryptoStore::sr25519_generate_new(
 			&*test_state.keystore,
 			ValidatorId::ID,
@@ -497,7 +500,7 @@ fn backing_works() {
 					timeout,
 					tx,
 				)
-			) if pov == pov && &c == candidate_a.descriptor() && timeout == BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT => {
+			) if pov == pov && c.descriptor() == candidate_a.descriptor() && timeout == BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT && c.commitments_hash == candidate_a_commitments_hash=> {
 				tx.send(Ok(
 					ValidationResult::Valid(CandidateCommitments {
 						head_data: expected_head_data.clone(),
@@ -594,6 +597,8 @@ fn backing_works_while_validation_ongoing() {
 		.build();
 
 		let candidate_a_hash = candidate_a.hash();
+		let candidate_a_commitments_hash = candidate_a.commitments.hash();
+
 		let public1 = CryptoStore::sr25519_generate_new(
 			&*test_state.keystore,
 			ValidatorId::ID,
@@ -691,7 +696,7 @@ fn backing_works_while_validation_ongoing() {
 					timeout,
 					tx,
 				)
-			) if pov == pov && &c == candidate_a.descriptor() && timeout == BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT => {
+			) if pov == pov && c.descriptor() == candidate_a.descriptor() && timeout == BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT && candidate_a_commitments_hash == c.commitments_hash => {
 				// we never validate the candidate. our local node
 				// shouldn't issue any statements.
 				std::mem::forget(tx);
@@ -799,6 +804,8 @@ fn backing_misbehavior_works() {
 		.build();
 
 		let candidate_a_hash = candidate_a.hash();
+		let candidate_a_commitments_hash = candidate_a.commitments.hash();
+
 		let public2 = CryptoStore::sr25519_generate_new(
 			&*test_state.keystore,
 			ValidatorId::ID,
@@ -865,7 +872,7 @@ fn backing_misbehavior_works() {
 					timeout,
 					tx,
 				)
-			) if pov == pov && &c == candidate_a.descriptor() && timeout == BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT => {
+			) if pov == pov && c.descriptor() == candidate_a.descriptor() && timeout == BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT && candidate_a_commitments_hash == c.commitments_hash => {
 				tx.send(Ok(
 					ValidationResult::Valid(CandidateCommitments {
 						head_data: expected_head_data.clone(),
@@ -1025,7 +1032,7 @@ fn backing_dont_second_invalid() {
 					timeout,
 					tx,
 				)
-			) if pov == pov && &c == candidate_a.descriptor() && timeout == BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT => {
+			) if pov == pov && c.descriptor() == candidate_a.descriptor() && timeout == BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT => {
 				tx.send(Ok(ValidationResult::Invalid(InvalidCandidate::BadReturn))).unwrap();
 			}
 		);
@@ -1054,7 +1061,7 @@ fn backing_dont_second_invalid() {
 					timeout,
 					tx,
 				)
-			) if pov == pov && &c == candidate_b.descriptor() && timeout == BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT => {
+			) if pov == pov && c.descriptor() == candidate_b.descriptor() && timeout == BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT => {
 				tx.send(Ok(
 					ValidationResult::Valid(CandidateCommitments {
 						head_data: expected_head_data.clone(),
@@ -1185,7 +1192,7 @@ fn backing_second_after_first_fails_works() {
 					timeout,
 					tx,
 				)
-			) if pov == pov && &c == candidate.descriptor() && timeout == BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT => {
+			) if pov == pov && c.descriptor() == candidate.descriptor() && timeout == BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT && c.commitments_hash == candidate.commitments.hash() => {
 				tx.send(Ok(ValidationResult::Invalid(InvalidCandidate::BadReturn))).unwrap();
 			}
 		);
@@ -1319,7 +1326,7 @@ fn backing_works_after_failed_validation() {
 					timeout,
 					tx,
 				)
-			) if pov == pov && &c == candidate.descriptor() && timeout == BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT => {
+			) if pov == pov && c.descriptor() == candidate.descriptor() && timeout == BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT && c.commitments_hash == candidate.commitments.hash() => {
 				tx.send(Err(ValidationFailed("Internal test error".into()))).unwrap();
 			}
 		);
@@ -1696,7 +1703,7 @@ fn retry_works() {
 					timeout,
 					_tx,
 				)
-			) if pov == pov && &c == candidate.descriptor() && timeout == BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT
+			) if pov == pov && c.descriptor() == candidate.descriptor() && timeout == BACKING_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT && c.commitments_hash == candidate.commitments.hash()
 		);
 		virtual_overseer
 	});

polkadot/node/core/candidate-validation/src/lib.rs

@@ -41,7 +41,7 @@ use polkadot_node_subsystem::{
 use polkadot_node_subsystem_util::metrics::{self, prometheus};
 use polkadot_parachain::primitives::{ValidationParams, ValidationResult as WasmValidationResult};
 use polkadot_primitives::v2::{
-	CandidateCommitments, CandidateDescriptor, Hash, OccupiedCoreAssumption,
+	CandidateCommitments, CandidateDescriptor, CandidateReceipt, Hash, OccupiedCoreAssumption,
 	PersistedValidationData, ValidationCode, ValidationCodeHash,
 };
 
@@ -134,7 +134,7 @@ where
 			FromOverseer::Signal(OverseerSignal::Conclude) => return Ok(()),
 			FromOverseer::Communication { msg } => match msg {
 				CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromChainState(
-					descriptor,
+					candidate_receipt,
 					pov,
 					timeout,
 					response_sender,
@@ -149,7 +149,7 @@ where
 							let res = validate_from_chain_state(
 								&mut sender,
 								validation_host,
-								descriptor,
+								candidate_receipt,
 								pov,
 								timeout,
 								&metrics,
@@ -166,7 +166,7 @@ where
 				CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromExhaustive(
 					persisted_validation_data,
 					validation_code,
-					descriptor,
+					candidate_receipt,
 					pov,
 					timeout,
 					response_sender,
@@ -181,7 +181,7 @@ where
 								validation_host,
 								persisted_validation_data,
 								validation_code,
-								descriptor,
+								candidate_receipt,
 								pov,
 								timeout,
 								&metrics,
@@ -413,10 +413,32 @@ where
 	AssumptionCheckOutcome::DoesNotMatch
 }
 
+/// Returns validation data for a given candidate.
+pub async fn find_validation_data<Sender>(
+	sender: &mut Sender,
+	descriptor: &CandidateDescriptor,
+) -> Result<Option<(PersistedValidationData, ValidationCode)>, ValidationFailed>
+where
+	Sender: SubsystemSender,
+{
+	match find_assumed_validation_data(sender, &descriptor).await {
+		AssumptionCheckOutcome::Matches(validation_data, validation_code) =>
+			Ok(Some((validation_data, validation_code))),
+		AssumptionCheckOutcome::DoesNotMatch => {
+			// If neither the assumption of the occupied core having the para included or the assumption
+			// of the occupied core timing out are valid, then the persisted_validation_data_hash in the descriptor
+			// is not based on the relay parent and is thus invalid.
+			Ok(None)
+		},
+		AssumptionCheckOutcome::BadRequest =>
+			Err(ValidationFailed("Assumption Check: Bad request".into())),
+	}
+}
+
 async fn validate_from_chain_state<Sender>(
 	sender: &mut Sender,
 	validation_host: ValidationHost,
-	descriptor: CandidateDescriptor,
+	candidate_receipt: CandidateReceipt,
 	pov: Arc<PoV>,
 	timeout: Duration,
 	metrics: &Metrics,
@@ -424,25 +446,18 @@ async fn validate_from_chain_state<Sender>(
 where
 	Sender: SubsystemSender,
 {
+	let mut new_sender = sender.clone();
 	let (validation_data, validation_code) =
-		match find_assumed_validation_data(sender, &descriptor).await {
+		match find_validation_data(&mut new_sender, &candidate_receipt.descriptor).await? {
-			AssumptionCheckOutcome::Matches(validation_data, validation_code) =>
+			Some((validation_data, validation_code)) => (validation_data, validation_code),
-				(validation_data, validation_code),
+			None => return Ok(ValidationResult::Invalid(InvalidCandidate::BadParent)),
-			AssumptionCheckOutcome::DoesNotMatch => {
-				// If neither the assumption of the occupied core having the para included or the assumption
-				// of the occupied core timing out are valid, then the persisted_validation_data_hash in the descriptor
-				// is not based on the relay parent and is thus invalid.
-				return Ok(ValidationResult::Invalid(InvalidCandidate::BadParent))
-			},
-			AssumptionCheckOutcome::BadRequest =>
-				return Err(ValidationFailed("Assumption Check: Bad request".into())),
 		};
 
 	let validation_result = validate_candidate_exhaustive(
 		validation_host,
 		validation_data,
 		validation_code,
-		descriptor.clone(),
+		candidate_receipt.clone(),
 		pov,
 		timeout,
 		metrics,
@@ -450,11 +465,20 @@ where
 	.await;
 
 	if let Ok(ValidationResult::Valid(ref outputs, _)) = validation_result {
+		// If validation produces new commitments we consider the candidate invalid.
+		if candidate_receipt.commitments_hash != outputs.hash() {
+			return Ok(ValidationResult::Invalid(InvalidCandidate::CommitmentsHashMismatch))
+		}
+
 		let (tx, rx) = oneshot::channel();
 		match runtime_api_request(
 			sender,
-			descriptor.relay_parent,
+			candidate_receipt.descriptor.relay_parent,
-			RuntimeApiRequest::CheckValidationOutputs(descriptor.para_id, outputs.clone(), tx),
+			RuntimeApiRequest::CheckValidationOutputs(
+				candidate_receipt.descriptor.para_id,
+				outputs.clone(),
+				tx,
+			),
 			rx,
 		)
 		.await
@@ -473,7 +497,7 @@ async fn validate_candidate_exhaustive(
 	mut validation_backend: impl ValidationBackend,
 	persisted_validation_data: PersistedValidationData,
 	validation_code: ValidationCode,
-	descriptor: CandidateDescriptor,
+	candidate_receipt: CandidateReceipt,
 	pov: Arc<PoV>,
 	timeout: Duration,
 	metrics: &Metrics,
@@ -484,12 +508,12 @@ async fn validate_candidate_exhaustive(
 	gum::debug!(
 		target: LOG_TARGET,
 		?validation_code_hash,
-		para_id = ?descriptor.para_id,
+		para_id = ?candidate_receipt.descriptor.para_id,
 		"About to validate a candidate.",
 	);
 
 	if let Err(e) = perform_basic_checks(
-		&descriptor,
+		&candidate_receipt.descriptor,
 		persisted_validation_data.max_pov_size,
 		&*pov,
 		&validation_code_hash,
@@ -555,7 +579,7 @@ async fn validate_candidate_exhaustive(
 			Ok(ValidationResult::Invalid(InvalidCandidate::ExecutionError(e))),
 
 		Ok(res) =>
-			if res.head_data.hash() != descriptor.para_head {
+			if res.head_data.hash() != candidate_receipt.descriptor.para_head {
 				Ok(ValidationResult::Invalid(InvalidCandidate::ParaHeadHashMismatch))
 			} else {
 				let outputs = CandidateCommitments {
@@ -566,7 +590,12 @@ async fn validate_candidate_exhaustive(
 					processed_downward_messages: res.processed_downward_messages,
 					hrmp_watermark: res.hrmp_watermark,
 				};
+				if candidate_receipt.commitments_hash != outputs.hash() {
+					// If validation produced a new set of commitments, we treat the candidate as invalid.
+					Ok(ValidationResult::Invalid(InvalidCandidate::CommitmentsHashMismatch))
+				} else {
 					Ok(ValidationResult::Valid(outputs, persisted_validation_data))
+				}
 			},
 	}
 }

polkadot/node/core/candidate-validation/src/tests.rs

@@ -406,11 +406,22 @@ fn candidate_validation_ok_is_ok() {
 		hrmp_watermark: 0,
 	};
 
+	let commitments = CandidateCommitments {
+		head_data: validation_result.head_data.clone(),
+		upward_messages: validation_result.upward_messages.clone(),
+		horizontal_messages: validation_result.horizontal_messages.clone(),
+		new_validation_code: validation_result.new_validation_code.clone(),
+		processed_downward_messages: validation_result.processed_downward_messages,
+		hrmp_watermark: validation_result.hrmp_watermark,
+	};
+
+	let candidate_receipt = CandidateReceipt { descriptor, commitments_hash: commitments.hash() };
+
 	let v = executor::block_on(validate_candidate_exhaustive(
 		MockValidateCandidateBackend::with_hardcoded_result(Ok(validation_result)),
 		validation_data.clone(),
 		validation_code,
-		descriptor,
+		candidate_receipt,
 		Arc::new(pov),
 		Duration::from_secs(0),
 		&Default::default(),
@@ -453,13 +464,15 @@ fn candidate_validation_bad_return_is_invalid() {
 	);
 	assert!(check.is_ok());
 
+	let candidate_receipt = CandidateReceipt { descriptor, commitments_hash: Hash::zero() };
+
 	let v = executor::block_on(validate_candidate_exhaustive(
 		MockValidateCandidateBackend::with_hardcoded_result(Err(
 			ValidationError::InvalidCandidate(WasmInvalidCandidate::AmbiguousWorkerDeath),
 		)),
 		validation_data,
 		validation_code,
-		descriptor,
+		candidate_receipt,
 		Arc::new(pov),
 		Duration::from_secs(0),
 		&Default::default(),
@@ -495,13 +508,15 @@ fn candidate_validation_timeout_is_internal_error() {
 	);
 	assert!(check.is_ok());
 
+	let candidate_receipt = CandidateReceipt { descriptor, commitments_hash: Hash::zero() };
+
 	let v = executor::block_on(validate_candidate_exhaustive(
 		MockValidateCandidateBackend::with_hardcoded_result(Err(
 			ValidationError::InvalidCandidate(WasmInvalidCandidate::HardTimeout),
 		)),
 		validation_data,
 		validation_code,
-		descriptor,
+		candidate_receipt,
 		Arc::new(pov),
 		Duration::from_secs(0),
 		&Default::default(),
@@ -510,6 +525,52 @@ fn candidate_validation_timeout_is_internal_error() {
 	assert_matches!(v, Ok(ValidationResult::Invalid(InvalidCandidate::Timeout)));
 }
 
+#[test]
+fn candidate_validation_commitment_hash_mismatch_is_invalid() {
+	let validation_data = PersistedValidationData { max_pov_size: 1024, ..Default::default() };
+	let pov = PoV { block_data: BlockData(vec![0xff; 32]) };
+	let validation_code = ValidationCode(vec![0xff; 16]);
+	let head_data = HeadData(vec![1, 1, 1]);
+
+	let candidate_receipt = CandidateReceipt {
+		descriptor: make_valid_candidate_descriptor(
+			1.into(),
+			validation_data.parent_head.hash(),
+			validation_data.hash(),
+			pov.hash(),
+			validation_code.hash(),
+			head_data.hash(),
+			dummy_hash(),
+			Sr25519Keyring::Alice,
+		),
+		commitments_hash: Hash::zero(),
+	};
+
+	// This will result in different commitments for this candidate.
+	let validation_result = WasmValidationResult {
+		head_data,
+		new_validation_code: None,
+		upward_messages: Vec::new(),
+		horizontal_messages: Vec::new(),
+		processed_downward_messages: 0,
+		hrmp_watermark: 12345,
+	};
+
+	let result = executor::block_on(validate_candidate_exhaustive(
+		MockValidateCandidateBackend::with_hardcoded_result(Ok(validation_result)),
+		validation_data,
+		validation_code,
+		candidate_receipt,
+		Arc::new(pov),
+		Duration::from_secs(0),
+		&Default::default(),
+	))
+	.unwrap();
+
+	// Ensure `post validation` check on the commitments hash works as expected.
+	assert_matches!(result, ValidationResult::Invalid(InvalidCandidate::CommitmentsHashMismatch));
+}
+
 #[test]
 fn candidate_validation_code_mismatch_is_invalid() {
 	let validation_data = PersistedValidationData { max_pov_size: 1024, ..Default::default() };
@@ -536,13 +597,15 @@ fn candidate_validation_code_mismatch_is_invalid() {
 	);
 	assert_matches!(check, Err(InvalidCandidate::CodeHashMismatch));
 
+	let candidate_receipt = CandidateReceipt { descriptor, commitments_hash: Hash::zero() };
+
 	let v = executor::block_on(validate_candidate_exhaustive(
 		MockValidateCandidateBackend::with_hardcoded_result(Err(
 			ValidationError::InvalidCandidate(WasmInvalidCandidate::HardTimeout),
 		)),
 		validation_data,
 		validation_code,
-		descriptor,
+		candidate_receipt,
 		Arc::new(pov),
 		Duration::from_secs(0),
 		&Default::default(),
@@ -583,11 +646,22 @@ fn compressed_code_works() {
 		hrmp_watermark: 0,
 	};
 
+	let commitments = CandidateCommitments {
+		head_data: validation_result.head_data.clone(),
+		upward_messages: validation_result.upward_messages.clone(),
+		horizontal_messages: validation_result.horizontal_messages.clone(),
+		new_validation_code: validation_result.new_validation_code.clone(),
+		processed_downward_messages: validation_result.processed_downward_messages,
+		hrmp_watermark: validation_result.hrmp_watermark,
+	};
+
+	let candidate_receipt = CandidateReceipt { descriptor, commitments_hash: commitments.hash() };
+
 	let v = executor::block_on(validate_candidate_exhaustive(
 		MockValidateCandidateBackend::with_hardcoded_result(Ok(validation_result)),
 		validation_data,
 		validation_code,
-		descriptor,
+		candidate_receipt,
 		Arc::new(pov),
 		Duration::from_secs(0),
 		&Default::default(),
@@ -628,11 +702,13 @@ fn code_decompression_failure_is_invalid() {
 		hrmp_watermark: 0,
 	};
 
+	let candidate_receipt = CandidateReceipt { descriptor, commitments_hash: Hash::zero() };
+
 	let v = executor::block_on(validate_candidate_exhaustive(
 		MockValidateCandidateBackend::with_hardcoded_result(Ok(validation_result)),
 		validation_data,
 		validation_code,
-		descriptor,
+		candidate_receipt,
 		Arc::new(pov),
 		Duration::from_secs(0),
 		&Default::default(),
@@ -674,11 +750,13 @@ fn pov_decompression_failure_is_invalid() {
 		hrmp_watermark: 0,
 	};
 
+	let candidate_receipt = CandidateReceipt { descriptor, commitments_hash: Hash::zero() };
+
 	let v = executor::block_on(validate_candidate_exhaustive(
 		MockValidateCandidateBackend::with_hardcoded_result(Ok(validation_result)),
 		validation_data,
 		validation_code,
-		descriptor,
+		candidate_receipt,
 		Arc::new(pov),
 		Duration::from_secs(0),
 		&Default::default(),

polkadot/node/core/dispute-coordinator/src/real/participation/mod.rs

@@ -362,7 +362,7 @@ async fn participate(
 			CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromExhaustive(
 				available_data.validation_data,
 				validation_code,
-				req.candidate_receipt().descriptor.clone(),
+				req.candidate_receipt().clone(),
 				available_data.pov,
 				APPROVAL_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT,
 				validation_tx,
@@ -393,6 +393,7 @@ async fn participate(
 
 			send_result(&mut result_sender, req, ParticipationOutcome::Invalid).await;
 		},
+
 		Ok(Ok(ValidationResult::Invalid(invalid))) => {
 			gum::warn!(
 				target: LOG_TARGET,
@@ -403,19 +404,8 @@ async fn participate(
 
 			send_result(&mut result_sender, req, ParticipationOutcome::Invalid).await;
 		},
-		Ok(Ok(ValidationResult::Valid(commitments, _))) => {
+		Ok(Ok(ValidationResult::Valid(_, _))) => {
-			if commitments.hash() != req.candidate_receipt().commitments_hash {
-				gum::warn!(
-					target: LOG_TARGET,
-					expected = ?req.candidate_receipt().commitments_hash,
-					got = ?commitments.hash(),
-					"Candidate is valid but commitments hash doesn't match",
-				);
-
-				send_result(&mut result_sender, req, ParticipationOutcome::Invalid).await;
-			} else {
 			send_result(&mut result_sender, req, ParticipationOutcome::Valid).await;
-			}
 		},
 	}
 }

polkadot/node/core/dispute-coordinator/src/real/participation/tests.rs

@@ -108,7 +108,10 @@ async fn activate_leaf(
 }
 
 /// Full participation happy path as seen via the overseer.
-pub async fn participation_full_happy_path(ctx_handle: &mut VirtualOverseer) {
+pub async fn participation_full_happy_path(
+	ctx_handle: &mut VirtualOverseer,
+	expected_commitments_hash: Hash,
+) {
 	recover_available_data(ctx_handle).await;
 	fetch_validation_code(ctx_handle).await;
 	store_available_data(ctx_handle, true).await;
@@ -116,9 +119,13 @@ pub async fn participation_full_happy_path(ctx_handle: &mut VirtualOverseer) {
 	assert_matches!(
 	ctx_handle.recv().await,
 	AllMessages::CandidateValidation(
-		CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromExhaustive(_, _, _, _, timeout, tx)
+		CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromExhaustive(_, _, candidate_receipt, _, timeout, tx)
 		) if timeout == APPROVAL_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT => {
+			if expected_commitments_hash != candidate_receipt.commitments_hash {
+				tx.send(Ok(ValidationResult::Invalid(InvalidCandidate::CommitmentsHashMismatch))).unwrap();
+			} else {
 				tx.send(Ok(ValidationResult::Valid(dummy_candidate_commitments(None), PersistedValidationData::default()))).unwrap();
+			}
 	},
 	"overseer did not receive candidate validation message",
 	);
@@ -438,7 +445,7 @@ fn cast_invalid_vote_if_validation_fails_or_is_invalid() {
 }
 
 #[test]
-fn cast_invalid_vote_if_validation_passes_but_commitments_dont_match() {
+fn cast_invalid_vote_if_commitments_dont_match() {
 	futures::executor::block_on(async {
 		let (mut ctx, mut ctx_handle) = make_our_subsystem_context(TaskExecutor::new());
 
@@ -459,11 +466,7 @@ fn cast_invalid_vote_if_validation_passes_but_commitments_dont_match() {
 			AllMessages::CandidateValidation(
 				CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromExhaustive(_, _, _, _, timeout, tx)
 			) if timeout == APPROVAL_EXECUTION_TIMEOUT => {
-				let mut commitments = CandidateCommitments::default();
+				tx.send(Ok(ValidationResult::Invalid(InvalidCandidate::CommitmentsHashMismatch))).unwrap();
-				// this should lead to a commitments hash mismatch
-				commitments.processed_downward_messages = 42;
-
-				tx.send(Ok(ValidationResult::Valid(commitments, PersistedValidationData::default()))).unwrap();
 			},
 			"overseer did not receive candidate validation message",
 		);

polkadot/node/core/dispute-coordinator/src/real/tests.rs

@@ -407,8 +407,9 @@ where
 async fn participation_with_distribution(
 	virtual_overseer: &mut VirtualOverseer,
 	candidate_hash: &CandidateHash,
+	expected_commitments_hash: Hash,
 ) {
-	participation_full_happy_path(virtual_overseer).await;
+	participation_full_happy_path(virtual_overseer, expected_commitments_hash).await;
 	assert_matches!(
 		virtual_overseer.recv().await,
 		AllMessages::DisputeDistribution(
@@ -426,7 +427,6 @@ fn make_valid_candidate_receipt() -> CandidateReceipt {
 }
 
 fn make_invalid_candidate_receipt() -> CandidateReceipt {
-	// Commitments hash will be 0, which is not correct:
 	dummy_candidate_receipt_bad_sig(Default::default(), Some(Default::default()))
 }
 
@@ -593,7 +593,12 @@ fn dispute_gets_confirmed_via_participation() {
 				})
 				.await;
 
-			participation_with_distribution(&mut virtual_overseer, &candidate_hash1).await;
+			participation_with_distribution(
+				&mut virtual_overseer,
+				&candidate_hash1,
+				candidate_receipt1.commitments_hash,
+			)
+			.await;
 
 			{
 				let (tx, rx) = oneshot::channel();
@@ -942,7 +947,12 @@ fn conflicting_votes_lead_to_dispute_participation() {
 				})
 				.await;
 
-			participation_with_distribution(&mut virtual_overseer, &candidate_hash).await;
+			participation_with_distribution(
+				&mut virtual_overseer,
+				&candidate_hash,
+				candidate_receipt.commitments_hash,
+			)
+			.await;
 
 			{
 				let (tx, rx) = oneshot::channel();
@@ -1224,7 +1234,12 @@ fn finality_votes_ignore_disputed_candidates() {
 				})
 				.await;
 
-			participation_with_distribution(&mut virtual_overseer, &candidate_hash).await;
+			participation_with_distribution(
+				&mut virtual_overseer,
+				&candidate_hash,
+				candidate_receipt.commitments_hash,
+			)
+			.await;
 
 			{
 				let (tx, rx) = oneshot::channel();
@@ -1322,7 +1337,12 @@ fn supermajority_valid_dispute_may_be_finalized() {
 				})
 				.await;
 
-			participation_with_distribution(&mut virtual_overseer, &candidate_hash).await;
+			participation_with_distribution(
+				&mut virtual_overseer,
+				&candidate_hash,
+				candidate_receipt.commitments_hash,
+			)
+			.await;
 
 			let mut statements = Vec::new();
 			for i in (0..supermajority_threshold - 1).map(|i| i + 3) {
@@ -1442,7 +1462,12 @@ fn concluded_supermajority_for_non_active_after_time() {
 				})
 				.await;
 
-			participation_with_distribution(&mut virtual_overseer, &candidate_hash).await;
+			participation_with_distribution(
+				&mut virtual_overseer,
+				&candidate_hash,
+				candidate_receipt.commitments_hash,
+			)
+			.await;
 
 			let mut statements = Vec::new();
 			// -2: 1 for already imported vote and one for local vote (which is valid).
@@ -1543,7 +1568,13 @@ fn concluded_supermajority_against_non_active_after_time() {
 				ImportStatementsResult::ValidImport => {}
 			);
 
-			participation_with_distribution(&mut virtual_overseer, &candidate_hash).await;
+			// Use a different expected commitments hash to ensure the candidate validation returns invalid.
+			participation_with_distribution(
+				&mut virtual_overseer,
+				&candidate_hash,
+				CandidateCommitments::default().hash(),
+			)
+			.await;
 
 			let mut statements = Vec::new();
 			// minus 2, because of local vote and one previously imported invalid vote.
@@ -1580,7 +1611,6 @@ fn concluded_supermajority_against_non_active_after_time() {
 					.await;
 
 				assert!(rx.await.unwrap().is_empty());
-
 				let (tx, rx) = oneshot::channel();
 
 				virtual_overseer
@@ -1672,7 +1702,12 @@ fn resume_dispute_without_local_statement() {
 			let candidate_receipt = make_valid_candidate_receipt();
 			let candidate_hash = candidate_receipt.hash();
 
-			participation_with_distribution(&mut virtual_overseer, &candidate_hash).await;
+			participation_with_distribution(
+				&mut virtual_overseer,
+				&candidate_hash,
+				candidate_receipt.commitments_hash,
+			)
+			.await;
 
 			let valid_vote0 = test_state
 				.issue_explicit_statement_with_index(0, candidate_hash, session, true)

polkadot/node/malus/Cargo.toml

@@ -28,10 +28,12 @@ color-eyre = { version = "0.6.1", default-features = false }
 assert_matches = "1.5"
 async-trait = "0.1.53"
 sp-keystore = { git = "https://github.com/paritytech/substrate", branch = "master" }
+sp-core = { git = "https://github.com/paritytech/substrate", branch = "master" }
 clap = { version = "3.1", features = ["derive"] }
 futures = "0.3.21"
 futures-timer = "3.0.2"
 gum = { package = "tracing-gum", path = "../gum/" }
+erasure = { package = "polkadot-erasure-coding", path = "../../erasure-coding" }
 
 [features]
 default = []

polkadot/node/malus/src/malus.rs

@@ -37,7 +37,7 @@ enum NemesisVariant {
 	/// Back a candidate with a specifically crafted proof of validity.
 	BackGarbageCandidate(RunCmd),
 	/// Delayed disputing of ancestors that are perfectly fine.
-	DisputeAncestor(RunCmd),
+	DisputeAncestor(DisputeAncestorOptions),
 
 	#[allow(missing_docs)]
 	#[clap(name = "prepare-worker", hide = true)]
@@ -66,9 +66,11 @@ impl MalusCli {
 			NemesisVariant::BackGarbageCandidate(cmd) =>
 				polkadot_cli::run_node(run_cmd(cmd), BackGarbageCandidate)?,
 			NemesisVariant::SuggestGarbageCandidate(cmd) =>
-				polkadot_cli::run_node(run_cmd(cmd), SuggestGarbageCandidate)?,
+				polkadot_cli::run_node(run_cmd(cmd), BackGarbageCandidateWrapper)?,
-			NemesisVariant::DisputeAncestor(cmd) =>
+			NemesisVariant::DisputeAncestor(opts) => polkadot_cli::run_node(
-				polkadot_cli::run_node(run_cmd(cmd), DisputeValidCandidates)?,
+				run_cmd(opts.clone().cmd),
+				DisputeValidCandidates::new(opts),
+			)?,
 			NemesisVariant::PvfPrepareWorker(cmd) => {
 				#[cfg(target_os = "android")]
 				{
@@ -120,7 +122,7 @@ mod tests {
 			variant: NemesisVariant::DisputeAncestor(run),
 			..
 		} => {
-			assert!(run.base.bob);
+			assert!(run.cmd.base.bob);
 		});
 	}
 }

polkadot/node/malus/src/shared.rs

@@ -17,7 +17,7 @@
 use futures::prelude::*;
 use polkadot_node_primitives::SpawnNamed;
 
-pub const MALUS: &str = "MALUS😈😈😈";
+pub const MALUS: &str = "MALUS";
 
 #[allow(unused)]
 pub(crate) const MALICIOUS_POV: &[u8] = "😈😈pov_looks_valid_to_me😈😈".as_bytes();

polkadot/node/malus/src/variants/back_garbage_candidate.rs

@@ -14,10 +14,9 @@
 // You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License
 // along with Polkadot.  If not, see <http://www.gnu.org/licenses/>.
 
-//! A malicious overseer backing a particular candidate with a
+//! This variant of Malus backs/approves all malicious candidates crafted by
-//! malicious proof of validity that is received.
+//! `suggest-garbage-candidate` variant and behaves honestly with other
-
+//! candidates.
-#![allow(missing_docs)]
 
 use polkadot_cli::{
 	prepared_overseer_builder,
@@ -28,170 +27,15 @@ use polkadot_cli::{
 	},
 };
 
-// Import extra types relevant to the particular
+use crate::{
-// subsystem.
+	interceptor::*,
-use polkadot_node_core_candidate_validation::CandidateValidationSubsystem;
+	variants::{FakeCandidateValidation, FakeCandidateValidationError, ReplaceValidationResult},
-use polkadot_node_subsystem::messages::{
-	AvailabilityRecoveryMessage, CandidateValidationMessage, ValidationFailed,
-};
-use polkadot_node_subsystem_util as util;
-
-// Filter wrapping related types.
-use crate::{interceptor::*, shared::*};
-use polkadot_node_primitives::{PoV, ValidationResult};
-
-use polkadot_primitives::v2::{
-	CandidateCommitments, CandidateDescriptor, CandidateReceipt, PersistedValidationData,
-	ValidationCode,
 };
 
-use futures::channel::oneshot;
+use std::sync::Arc;
-use std::{
-	collections::HashMap,
-	sync::{Arc, Mutex},
-};
 
-#[derive(Clone, Debug)]
+/// Generates an overseer that replaces the candidate validation subsystem with our malicious
-struct BribedPassageInner<Spawner> {
+/// variant.
-	spawner: Spawner,
-	cache: HashMap<CandidateDescriptor, CandidateReceipt>,
-}
-
-#[derive(Clone, Debug)]
-struct BribedPassage<Spawner> {
-	inner: Arc<Mutex<BribedPassageInner<Spawner>>>,
-}
-
-impl<Spawner> BribedPassage<Spawner>
-where
-	Spawner: SpawnNamed,
-{
-	fn let_pass(
-		persisted_validation_data: PersistedValidationData,
-		validation_code: Option<ValidationCode>,
-		_candidate_descriptor: CandidateDescriptor,
-		_pov: Arc<PoV>,
-		response_sender: oneshot::Sender<Result<ValidationResult, ValidationFailed>>,
-	) {
-		let candidate_commitmentments = CandidateCommitments {
-			head_data: persisted_validation_data.parent_head.clone(),
-			new_validation_code: validation_code,
-			..Default::default()
-		};
-
-		response_sender
-			.send(Ok(ValidationResult::Valid(candidate_commitmentments, persisted_validation_data)))
-			.unwrap();
-	}
-}
-
-impl<Sender, Spawner> MessageInterceptor<Sender> for BribedPassage<Spawner>
-where
-	Sender: overseer::SubsystemSender<CandidateValidationMessage>
-		+ overseer::SubsystemSender<AllMessages>
-		+ Clone
-		+ Send
-		+ 'static,
-	Spawner: SpawnNamed + Send + Clone + 'static,
-{
-	type Message = CandidateValidationMessage;
-
-	fn intercept_incoming(
-		&self,
-		sender: &mut Sender,
-		msg: FromOverseer<Self::Message>,
-	) -> Option<FromOverseer<Self::Message>> {
-		match msg {
-			FromOverseer::Communication {
-				msg:
-					CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromExhaustive(
-						persisted_validation_data,
-						validation_code,
-						candidate_descriptor,
-						pov,
-						_duration,
-						response_sender,
-					),
-			} if pov.block_data.0.as_slice() == MALICIOUS_POV => {
-				Self::let_pass(
-					persisted_validation_data,
-					Some(validation_code),
-					candidate_descriptor,
-					pov,
-					response_sender,
-				);
-				None
-			},
-			FromOverseer::Communication {
-				msg:
-					CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromChainState(
-						candidate_descriptor,
-						pov,
-						_duration,
-						response_sender,
-					),
-			} if pov.block_data.0.as_slice() == MALICIOUS_POV => {
-				if let Some(candidate_receipt) =
-					self.inner.lock().unwrap().cache.get(&candidate_descriptor).cloned()
-				{
-					let mut subsystem_sender = sender.clone();
-					let spawner = self.inner.lock().unwrap().spawner.clone();
-					spawner.spawn(
-						"malus-back-garbage-adhoc",
-						Some("malus"),
-						Box::pin(async move {
-							let relay_parent = candidate_descriptor.relay_parent;
-							let session_index = util::request_session_index_for_child(
-								relay_parent,
-								&mut subsystem_sender,
-							)
-							.await;
-							let session_index = session_index.await.unwrap().unwrap();
-
-							let (a_tx, a_rx) = oneshot::channel();
-
-							subsystem_sender
-								.send_message(AllMessages::from(
-									AvailabilityRecoveryMessage::RecoverAvailableData(
-										candidate_receipt,
-										session_index,
-										None,
-										a_tx,
-									),
-								))
-								.await;
-
-							if let Ok(Ok(availability_data)) = a_rx.await {
-								Self::let_pass(
-									availability_data.validation_data,
-									None,
-									candidate_descriptor,
-									pov,
-									response_sender,
-								);
-							} else {
-								gum::info!(
-									target: MALUS,
-									"Could not get availability data, can't back"
-								);
-							}
-						}),
-					);
-				} else {
-					gum::info!(target: MALUS, "No CandidateReceipt available to work with");
-				}
-				None
-			},
-			msg => Some(msg),
-		}
-	}
-
-	fn intercept_outgoing(&self, msg: AllMessages) -> Option<AllMessages> {
-		Some(msg)
-	}
-}
-
-/// Generates an overseer that exposes bad behavior.
 pub(crate) struct BackGarbageCandidate;
 
 impl OverseerGen for BackGarbageCandidate {
@@ -205,24 +49,16 @@ impl OverseerGen for BackGarbageCandidate {
 		RuntimeClient::Api: ParachainHost<Block> + BabeApi<Block> + AuthorityDiscoveryApi<Block>,
 		Spawner: 'static + SpawnNamed + Clone + Unpin,
 	{
-		let candidate_validation_config = args.candidate_validation_config.clone();
 		let spawner = args.spawner.clone();
+		let validation_filter = ReplaceValidationResult::new(
+			FakeCandidateValidation::BackingAndApprovalValid,
+			FakeCandidateValidationError::InvalidOutputs,
+			spawner.clone(),
+		);
 
 		prepared_overseer_builder(args)?
-			.replace_candidate_validation(|cv| {
+			.replace_candidate_validation(move |cv_subsystem| {
-				InterceptedSubsystem::new(
+				InterceptedSubsystem::new(cv_subsystem, validation_filter)
-					CandidateValidationSubsystem::with_config(
-						candidate_validation_config,
-						cv.metrics,
-						cv.pvf_metrics,
-					),
-					BribedPassage::<Spawner> {
-						inner: Arc::new(Mutex::new(BribedPassageInner {
-							spawner,
-							cache: Default::default(),
-						})),
-					},
-				)
 			})
 			.build_with_connector(connector)
 			.map_err(|e| e.into())

polkadot/node/malus/src/variants/common.rs

@@ -0,0 +1,342 @@
+// Copyright 2022 Parity Technologies (UK) Ltd.
+// This file is part of Polkadot.
+
+// Polkadot is free software: you can redistribute it and/or modify
+// it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by
+// the Free Software Foundation, either version 3 of the License, or
+// (at your option) any later version.
+
+// Polkadot is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
+// but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
+// MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the
+// GNU General Public License for more details.
+
+// You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License
+// along with Polkadot.  If not, see <http://www.gnu.org/licenses/>.
+
+//! Implements common code for nemesis. Currently, only `FakeValidationResult`
+//! interceptor is implemented.
+use crate::{
+	interceptor::*,
+	shared::{MALICIOUS_POV, MALUS},
+};
+
+use polkadot_node_core_candidate_validation::find_validation_data;
+use polkadot_node_primitives::{InvalidCandidate, ValidationResult};
+use polkadot_node_subsystem::messages::{CandidateValidationMessage, ValidationFailed};
+
+use polkadot_primitives::v2::{
+	CandidateCommitments, CandidateDescriptor, CandidateReceipt, PersistedValidationData,
+};
+
+use polkadot_cli::service::SpawnNamed;
+
+use futures::channel::oneshot;
+
+#[derive(clap::ArgEnum, Clone, Copy, Debug, PartialEq)]
+#[clap(rename_all = "kebab-case")]
+#[non_exhaustive]
+pub enum FakeCandidateValidation {
+	Disabled,
+	BackingInvalid,
+	ApprovalInvalid,
+	BackingAndApprovalInvalid,
+	BackingValid,
+	ApprovalValid,
+	BackingAndApprovalValid,
+}
+
+/// Candidate invalidity details
+#[derive(clap::ArgEnum, Clone, Copy, Debug, PartialEq)]
+#[clap(rename_all = "kebab-case")]
+pub enum FakeCandidateValidationError {
+	/// Validation outputs check doesn't pass.
+	InvalidOutputs,
+	/// Failed to execute.`validate_block`. This includes function panicking.
+	ExecutionError,
+	/// Execution timeout.
+	Timeout,
+	/// Validation input is over the limit.
+	ParamsTooLarge,
+	/// Code size is over the limit.
+	CodeTooLarge,
+	/// Code does not decompress correctly.
+	CodeDecompressionFailure,
+	/// PoV does not decompress correctly.
+	POVDecompressionFailure,
+	/// Validation function returned invalid data.
+	BadReturn,
+	/// Invalid relay chain parent.
+	BadParent,
+	/// POV hash does not match.
+	POVHashMismatch,
+	/// Bad collator signature.
+	BadSignature,
+	/// Para head hash does not match.
+	ParaHeadHashMismatch,
+	/// Validation code hash does not match.
+	CodeHashMismatch,
+}
+
+impl Into<InvalidCandidate> for FakeCandidateValidationError {
+	fn into(self) -> InvalidCandidate {
+		match self {
+			FakeCandidateValidationError::ExecutionError =>
+				InvalidCandidate::ExecutionError("Malus".into()),
+			FakeCandidateValidationError::InvalidOutputs => InvalidCandidate::InvalidOutputs,
+			FakeCandidateValidationError::Timeout => InvalidCandidate::Timeout,
+			FakeCandidateValidationError::ParamsTooLarge => InvalidCandidate::ParamsTooLarge(666),
+			FakeCandidateValidationError::CodeTooLarge => InvalidCandidate::CodeTooLarge(666),
+			FakeCandidateValidationError::CodeDecompressionFailure =>
+				InvalidCandidate::CodeDecompressionFailure,
+			FakeCandidateValidationError::POVDecompressionFailure =>
+				InvalidCandidate::PoVDecompressionFailure,
+			FakeCandidateValidationError::BadReturn => InvalidCandidate::BadReturn,
+			FakeCandidateValidationError::BadParent => InvalidCandidate::BadParent,
+			FakeCandidateValidationError::POVHashMismatch => InvalidCandidate::PoVHashMismatch,
+			FakeCandidateValidationError::BadSignature => InvalidCandidate::BadSignature,
+			FakeCandidateValidationError::ParaHeadHashMismatch =>
+				InvalidCandidate::ParaHeadHashMismatch,
+			FakeCandidateValidationError::CodeHashMismatch => InvalidCandidate::CodeHashMismatch,
+		}
+	}
+}
+
+#[derive(Clone, Debug)]
+/// An interceptor which fakes validation result with a preconfigured result.
+/// Replaces `CandidateValidationSubsystem`.
+pub struct ReplaceValidationResult<Spawner> {
+	fake_validation: FakeCandidateValidation,
+	fake_validation_error: FakeCandidateValidationError,
+	spawner: Spawner,
+}
+
+impl<Spawner> ReplaceValidationResult<Spawner>
+where
+	Spawner: SpawnNamed,
+{
+	pub fn new(
+		fake_validation: FakeCandidateValidation,
+		fake_validation_error: FakeCandidateValidationError,
+		spawner: Spawner,
+	) -> Self {
+		Self { fake_validation, fake_validation_error, spawner }
+	}
+
+	/// Creates and sends the validation response for a given candidate. Queries the runtime to obtain the validation data for the
+	/// given candidate.
+	pub fn send_validation_response<Sender>(
+		&self,
+		candidate_descriptor: CandidateDescriptor,
+		subsystem_sender: Sender,
+		response_sender: oneshot::Sender<Result<ValidationResult, ValidationFailed>>,
+	) where
+		Sender: overseer::SubsystemSender<AllMessages>
+			+ overseer::SubsystemSender<CandidateValidationMessage>
+			+ Clone
+			+ Send
+			+ 'static,
+	{
+		let _candidate_descriptor = candidate_descriptor.clone();
+		let mut subsystem_sender = subsystem_sender.clone();
+		let (sender, receiver) = std::sync::mpsc::channel();
+		self.spawner.spawn_blocking(
+			"malus-get-validation-data",
+			Some("malus"),
+			Box::pin(async move {
+				match find_validation_data(&mut subsystem_sender, &_candidate_descriptor).await {
+					Ok(Some((validation_data, validation_code))) => {
+						sender
+							.send((validation_data, validation_code))
+							.expect("channel is still open");
+					},
+					_ => {
+						panic!("Unable to fetch validation data");
+					},
+				}
+			}),
+		);
+		let (validation_data, _) = receiver.recv().unwrap();
+		create_validation_response(validation_data, candidate_descriptor, response_sender);
+	}
+}
+
+pub fn create_fake_candidate_commitments(
+	persisted_validation_data: &PersistedValidationData,
+) -> CandidateCommitments {
+	CandidateCommitments {
+		upward_messages: Vec::new(),
+		horizontal_messages: Vec::new(),
+		new_validation_code: None,
+		head_data: persisted_validation_data.parent_head.clone(),
+		processed_downward_messages: 0,
+		hrmp_watermark: persisted_validation_data.relay_parent_number,
+	}
+}
+
+// Create and send validation response. This function needs the persistent validation data.
+fn create_validation_response(
+	persisted_validation_data: PersistedValidationData,
+	descriptor: CandidateDescriptor,
+	response_sender: oneshot::Sender<Result<ValidationResult, ValidationFailed>>,
+) {
+	let commitments = create_fake_candidate_commitments(&persisted_validation_data);
+
+	// Craft the new malicious candidate.
+	let candidate_receipt = CandidateReceipt { descriptor, commitments_hash: commitments.hash() };
+
+	let result = Ok(ValidationResult::Valid(commitments, persisted_validation_data));
+
+	gum::debug!(
+		target: MALUS,
+		para_id = ?candidate_receipt.descriptor.para_id,
+		candidate_hash = ?candidate_receipt.hash(),
+		"ValidationResult: {:?}",
+		&result
+	);
+
+	response_sender.send(result).unwrap();
+}
+
+impl<Sender, Spawner> MessageInterceptor<Sender> for ReplaceValidationResult<Spawner>
+where
+	Sender: overseer::SubsystemSender<CandidateValidationMessage>
+		+ overseer::SubsystemSender<AllMessages>
+		+ Clone
+		+ Send
+		+ 'static,
+	Spawner: SpawnNamed + Clone + 'static,
+{
+	type Message = CandidateValidationMessage;
+
+	// Capture all candidate validation requests and depending on configuration fail them.
+	fn intercept_incoming(
+		&self,
+		subsystem_sender: &mut Sender,
+		msg: FromOverseer<Self::Message>,
+	) -> Option<FromOverseer<Self::Message>> {
+		match msg {
+			FromOverseer::Communication {
+				msg:
+					CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromExhaustive(
+						validation_data,
+						validation_code,
+						candidate_receipt,
+						pov,
+						timeout,
+						sender,
+					),
+			} => {
+				match self.fake_validation {
+					FakeCandidateValidation::ApprovalValid |
+					FakeCandidateValidation::BackingAndApprovalValid => {
+						// Behave normally if the `PoV` is not known to be malicious.
+						if pov.block_data.0.as_slice() != MALICIOUS_POV {
+							return Some(FromOverseer::Communication {
+								msg: CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromExhaustive(
+									validation_data,
+									validation_code,
+									candidate_receipt,
+									pov,
+									timeout,
+									sender,
+								),
+							})
+						}
+						create_validation_response(
+							validation_data,
+							candidate_receipt.descriptor,
+							sender,
+						);
+						None
+					},
+					FakeCandidateValidation::ApprovalInvalid |
+					FakeCandidateValidation::BackingAndApprovalInvalid => {
+						let validation_result =
+							ValidationResult::Invalid(InvalidCandidate::InvalidOutputs);
+
+						gum::debug!(
+							target: MALUS,
+							para_id = ?candidate_receipt.descriptor.para_id,
+							"ValidateFromExhaustive result: {:?}",
+							&validation_result
+						);
+						// We're not even checking the candidate, this makes us appear faster than honest validators.
+						sender.send(Ok(validation_result)).unwrap();
+						None
+					},
+					_ => Some(FromOverseer::Communication {
+						msg: CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromExhaustive(
+							validation_data,
+							validation_code,
+							candidate_receipt,
+							pov,
+							timeout,
+							sender,
+						),
+					}),
+				}
+			},
+			FromOverseer::Communication {
+				msg:
+					CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromChainState(
+						candidate_receipt,
+						pov,
+						timeout,
+						response_sender,
+					),
+			} => {
+				match self.fake_validation {
+					FakeCandidateValidation::BackingValid |
+					FakeCandidateValidation::BackingAndApprovalValid => {
+						// Behave normally if the `PoV` is not known to be malicious.
+						if pov.block_data.0.as_slice() != MALICIOUS_POV {
+							return Some(FromOverseer::Communication {
+								msg: CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromChainState(
+									candidate_receipt,
+									pov,
+									timeout,
+									response_sender,
+								),
+							})
+						}
+						self.send_validation_response(
+							candidate_receipt.descriptor,
+							subsystem_sender.clone(),
+							response_sender,
+						);
+						None
+					},
+					FakeCandidateValidation::BackingInvalid |
+					FakeCandidateValidation::BackingAndApprovalInvalid => {
+						let validation_result =
+							ValidationResult::Invalid(self.fake_validation_error.clone().into());
+						gum::debug!(
+							target: MALUS,
+							para_id = ?candidate_receipt.descriptor.para_id,
+							"ValidateFromChainState result: {:?}",
+							&validation_result
+						);
+
+						// We're not even checking the candidate, this makes us appear faster than honest validators.
+						response_sender.send(Ok(validation_result)).unwrap();
+						None
+					},
+					_ => Some(FromOverseer::Communication {
+						msg: CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromChainState(
+							candidate_receipt,
+							pov,
+							timeout,
+							response_sender,
+						),
+					}),
+				}
+			},
+			msg => Some(msg),
+		}
+	}
+
+	fn intercept_outgoing(&self, msg: AllMessages) -> Option<AllMessages> {
+		Some(msg)
+	}
+}

polkadot/node/malus/src/variants/dispute_valid_candidates.rs

@@ -15,7 +15,8 @@
 // along with Polkadot.  If not, see <http://www.gnu.org/licenses/>.
 
 //! A malicious node that replaces approvals with invalid disputes
-//! against valid candidates.
+//! against valid candidates. Additionally, the malus node can be configured to
+//! fake candidate validation and return a static result for candidate checking.
 //!
 //! Attention: For usage with `zombienet` only!
 
@@ -28,70 +29,44 @@ use polkadot_cli::{
 		OverseerConnector, OverseerGen, OverseerGenArgs, OverseerHandle, ParachainHost,
 		ProvideRuntimeApi, SpawnNamed,
 	},
+	RunCmd,
 };
 
 // Filter wrapping related types.
-use crate::interceptor::*;
+use super::common::{FakeCandidateValidation, FakeCandidateValidationError};
-
+use crate::{interceptor::*, variants::ReplaceValidationResult};
-// Import extra types relevant to the particular
-// subsystem.
-use polkadot_node_core_backing::CandidateBackingSubsystem;
-use polkadot_node_subsystem::messages::{
-	ApprovalDistributionMessage, CandidateBackingMessage, DisputeCoordinatorMessage,
-};
-use sp_keystore::SyncCryptoStorePtr;
 
 use std::sync::Arc;
 
-/// Replace outgoing approval messages with disputes.
+#[derive(Clone, Debug, clap::Parser)]
-#[derive(Clone, Debug)]
+#[clap(rename_all = "kebab-case")]
-struct ReplaceApprovalsWithDisputes;
+#[allow(missing_docs)]
+pub struct DisputeAncestorOptions {
+	/// Malicious candidate validation subsystem configuration. When enabled, node PVF execution is skipped
+	/// during backing and/or approval and it's result can by specified by this option and `--fake-validation-error`
+	/// for invalid candidate outcomes.
+	#[clap(long, arg_enum, ignore_case = true, default_value_t = FakeCandidateValidation::BackingAndApprovalInvalid)]
+	pub fake_validation: FakeCandidateValidation,
 
-impl<Sender> MessageInterceptor<Sender> for ReplaceApprovalsWithDisputes
+	/// Applies only when `--fake-validation` is configured to reject candidates as invalid. It allows
-where
+	/// to specify the exact error to return from the malicious candidate validation subsystem.
-	Sender: overseer::SubsystemSender<CandidateBackingMessage> + Clone + Send + 'static,
+	#[clap(long, arg_enum, ignore_case = true, default_value_t = FakeCandidateValidationError::InvalidOutputs)]
-{
+	pub fake_validation_error: FakeCandidateValidationError,
-	type Message = CandidateBackingMessage;
 
-	fn intercept_incoming(
+	#[clap(flatten)]
-		&self,
+	pub cmd: RunCmd,
-		_sender: &mut Sender,
-		msg: FromOverseer<Self::Message>,
-	) -> Option<FromOverseer<Self::Message>> {
-		Some(msg)
 }
 
-	fn intercept_outgoing(&self, msg: AllMessages) -> Option<AllMessages> {
+pub(crate) struct DisputeValidCandidates {
-		match msg {
+	/// Fake validation config (applies to disputes as well).
-			AllMessages::ApprovalDistribution(ApprovalDistributionMessage::DistributeApproval(
+	opts: DisputeAncestorOptions,
-				_,
-			)) => {
-				// drop the message on the floor
-				None
-			},
-			AllMessages::DisputeCoordinator(DisputeCoordinatorMessage::ImportStatements {
-				candidate_hash,
-				candidate_receipt,
-				session,
-				..
-			}) => {
-				// this would also dispute candidates we were not assigned to approve
-				Some(AllMessages::DisputeCoordinator(
-					DisputeCoordinatorMessage::IssueLocalStatement(
-						session,
-						candidate_hash,
-						candidate_receipt,
-						false,
-					),
-				))
-			},
-			msg => Some(msg),
-		}
-	}
 }
 
-/// Generates an overseer that disputes instead of approving valid candidates.
+impl DisputeValidCandidates {
-pub(crate) struct DisputeValidCandidates;
+	pub fn new(opts: DisputeAncestorOptions) -> Self {
+		Self { opts }
+	}
+}
 
 impl OverseerGen for DisputeValidCandidates {
 	fn generate<'a, Spawner, RuntimeClient>(
@@ -105,15 +80,15 @@ impl OverseerGen for DisputeValidCandidates {
 		Spawner: 'static + SpawnNamed + Clone + Unpin,
 	{
 		let spawner = args.spawner.clone();
-		let crypto_store_ptr = args.keystore.clone() as SyncCryptoStorePtr;
+		let validation_filter = ReplaceValidationResult::new(
-		let filter = ReplaceApprovalsWithDisputes;
+			self.opts.fake_validation,
+			self.opts.fake_validation_error,
+			spawner.clone(),
+		);
 
 		prepared_overseer_builder(args)?
-			.replace_candidate_backing(move |cb| {
+			.replace_candidate_validation(move |cv_subsystem| {
-				InterceptedSubsystem::new(
+				InterceptedSubsystem::new(cv_subsystem, validation_filter)
-					CandidateBackingSubsystem::new(spawner, crypto_store_ptr, cb.params.metrics),
-					filter,
-				)
 			})
 			.build_with_connector(connector)
 			.map_err(|e| e.into())

polkadot/node/malus/src/variants/mod.rs

@@ -17,10 +17,13 @@
 //! Collection of behavior variants.
 
 mod back_garbage_candidate;
+mod common;
 mod dispute_valid_candidates;
 mod suggest_garbage_candidate;
 
 pub(crate) use self::{
-	back_garbage_candidate::BackGarbageCandidate, dispute_valid_candidates::DisputeValidCandidates,
+	back_garbage_candidate::BackGarbageCandidate,
-	suggest_garbage_candidate::SuggestGarbageCandidate,
+	dispute_valid_candidates::{DisputeAncestorOptions, DisputeValidCandidates},
+	suggest_garbage_candidate::BackGarbageCandidateWrapper,
 };
+pub(crate) use common::*;

polkadot/node/malus/src/variants/suggest_garbage_candidate.rs

@@ -14,11 +14,11 @@
 // You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License
 // along with Polkadot.  If not, see <http://www.gnu.org/licenses/>.
 
-//! A malicious overseer proposing a garbage block.
+//! A malicious node that stores bogus availability chunks, preventing others from
+//! doing approval voting. This should lead to disputes depending if the validator
+//! has fetched a malicious chunk.
 //!
-//! Supposed to be used with regular nodes or in conjunction
+//! Attention: For usage with `zombienet` only!
-//! with [`malus-back-garbage-candidate.rs`](./malus-back-garbage-candidate.rs)
-//! to simulate a coordinated attack.
 
 #![allow(missing_docs)]
 
@@ -30,73 +30,220 @@ use polkadot_cli::{
 		ProvideRuntimeApi, SpawnNamed,
 	},
 };
+use polkadot_node_core_candidate_validation::find_validation_data;
+use polkadot_node_primitives::{AvailableData, BlockData, PoV};
+use polkadot_primitives::v2::{CandidateDescriptor, CandidateHash};
+
+use polkadot_node_subsystem_util::request_validators;
+
+// Filter wrapping related types.
+use crate::{
+	interceptor::*,
+	shared::{MALICIOUS_POV, MALUS},
+	variants::{
+		create_fake_candidate_commitments, FakeCandidateValidation, FakeCandidateValidationError,
+		ReplaceValidationResult,
+	},
+};
 
 // Import extra types relevant to the particular
 // subsystem.
-use polkadot_node_core_backing::CandidateBackingSubsystem;
+use polkadot_node_subsystem::messages::{CandidateBackingMessage, CollatorProtocolMessage};
-use polkadot_node_primitives::Statement;
+use polkadot_primitives::v2::CandidateReceipt;
-use polkadot_node_subsystem::{
+
-	messages::{CandidateBackingMessage, StatementDistributionMessage},
+use std::{
-	overseer::{self, SubsystemSender},
+	collections::HashMap,
+	sync::{Arc, Mutex},
 };
-use polkadot_node_subsystem_util as util;
-// Filter wrapping related types.
-use crate::interceptor::*;
-use polkadot_primitives::v2::{
-	CandidateCommitments, CandidateReceipt, CommittedCandidateReceipt, CompactStatement, Hash,
-	Signed,
-};
-use sp_keystore::SyncCryptoStorePtr;
-use util::metered;
 
-use std::sync::Arc;
+struct Inner {
-
+	/// Maps malicious candidate hash to original candidate hash.
-use crate::shared::*;
+	/// It is used to replace outgoing collator protocol seconded messages.
-
+	map: HashMap<CandidateHash, CandidateHash>,
-/// Replaces the seconded PoV data
-/// of outgoing messages by some garbage data.
-#[derive(Clone)]
-struct ReplacePoVBytes<Sender>
-where
-	Sender: Send,
-{
-	queue: metered::UnboundedMeteredSender<(Sender, Hash, CandidateReceipt)>,
 }
 
-impl<Sender> MessageInterceptor<Sender> for ReplacePoVBytes<Sender>
+/// Replace outgoing approval messages with disputes.
+#[derive(Clone)]
+struct NoteCandidate<Spawner> {
+	inner: Arc<Mutex<Inner>>,
+	spawner: Spawner,
+}
+
+impl<Sender, Spawner> MessageInterceptor<Sender> for NoteCandidate<Spawner>
 where
-	Sender: overseer::SubsystemSender<CandidateBackingMessage> + Clone + Send + 'static,
+	Sender: overseer::SubsystemSender<AllMessages>
+		+ overseer::SubsystemSender<CandidateBackingMessage>
+		+ Clone
+		+ Send
+		+ 'static,
+	Spawner: SpawnNamed + Clone + 'static,
 {
 	type Message = CandidateBackingMessage;
 
+	/// Intercept incoming `Second` requests from the `collator-protocol` subsystem. We take
 	fn intercept_incoming(
 		&self,
-		sender: &mut Sender,
+		subsystem_sender: &mut Sender,
 		msg: FromOverseer<Self::Message>,
 	) -> Option<FromOverseer<Self::Message>> {
 		match msg {
 			FromOverseer::Communication {
-				msg: CandidateBackingMessage::Second(hash, candidate_receipt, _pov),
+				msg: CandidateBackingMessage::Second(relay_parent, candidate, _pov),
 			} => {
-				self.queue
+				gum::debug!(
-					.unbounded_send((sender.clone(), hash, candidate_receipt.clone()))
+					target: MALUS,
+					candidate_hash = ?candidate.hash(),
+					?relay_parent,
+					"Received request to second candidate"
+				);
+
+				let pov = PoV { block_data: BlockData(MALICIOUS_POV.into()) };
+
+				let (sender, receiver) = std::sync::mpsc::channel();
+				let mut new_sender = subsystem_sender.clone();
+				let _candidate = candidate.clone();
+				self.spawner.spawn_blocking(
+					"malus-get-validation-data",
+					Some("malus"),
+					Box::pin(async move {
+						gum::trace!(target: MALUS, "Requesting validators");
+						let n_validators = request_validators(relay_parent, &mut new_sender)
+							.await
+							.await
+							.unwrap()
+							.unwrap()
+							.len();
+						gum::trace!(target: MALUS, "Validators {}", n_validators);
+						match find_validation_data(&mut new_sender, &_candidate.descriptor()).await
+						{
+							Ok(Some((validation_data, validation_code))) => {
+								sender
+									.send((validation_data, validation_code, n_validators))
+									.expect("channel is still open");
+							},
+							_ => {
+								panic!("Unable to fetch validation data");
+							},
+						}
+					}),
+				);
+
+				let (validation_data, validation_code, n_validators) = receiver.recv().unwrap();
+
+				let validation_data_hash = validation_data.hash();
+				let validation_code_hash = validation_code.hash();
+				let validation_data_relay_parent_number = validation_data.relay_parent_number;
+
+				gum::trace!(
+					target: MALUS,
+					candidate_hash = ?candidate.hash(),
+					?relay_parent,
+					?n_validators,
+					?validation_data_hash,
+					?validation_code_hash,
+					?validation_data_relay_parent_number,
+					"Fetched validation data."
+				);
+
+				let malicious_available_data =
+					AvailableData { pov: Arc::new(pov.clone()), validation_data };
+
+				let pov_hash = pov.hash();
+				let erasure_root = {
+					let chunks =
+						erasure::obtain_chunks_v1(n_validators as usize, &malicious_available_data)
 							.unwrap();
 
-				None
+					let branches = erasure::branches(chunks.as_ref());
+					branches.root()
+				};
+
+				let (collator_id, collator_signature) = {
+					use polkadot_primitives::v2::CollatorPair;
+					use sp_core::crypto::Pair;
+
+					let collator_pair = CollatorPair::generate().0;
+					let signature_payload = polkadot_primitives::v2::collator_signature_payload(
+						&relay_parent,
+						&candidate.descriptor().para_id,
+						&validation_data_hash,
+						&pov_hash,
+						&validation_code_hash,
+					);
+
+					(collator_pair.public(), collator_pair.sign(&signature_payload))
+				};
+
+				let malicious_commitments =
+					create_fake_candidate_commitments(&malicious_available_data.validation_data);
+
+				let malicious_candidate = CandidateReceipt {
+					descriptor: CandidateDescriptor {
+						para_id: candidate.descriptor().para_id,
+						relay_parent,
+						collator: collator_id,
+						persisted_validation_data_hash: validation_data_hash,
+						pov_hash,
+						erasure_root,
+						signature: collator_signature,
+						para_head: malicious_commitments.head_data.hash(),
+						validation_code_hash,
 					},
-			other => Some(other),
+					commitments_hash: malicious_commitments.hash(),
+				};
+				let malicious_candidate_hash = malicious_candidate.hash();
+
+				gum::debug!(
+					target: MALUS,
+					candidate_hash = ?candidate.hash(),
+					?malicious_candidate_hash,
+					"Created malicious candidate"
+				);
+
+				// Map malicious candidate to the original one. We need this mapping to send back the correct seconded statement
+				// to the collators.
+				self.inner
+					.lock()
+					.expect("bad lock")
+					.map
+					.insert(malicious_candidate_hash, candidate.hash());
+
+				let message = FromOverseer::Communication {
+					msg: CandidateBackingMessage::Second(relay_parent, malicious_candidate, pov),
+				};
+
+				Some(message)
+			},
+			FromOverseer::Communication { msg } => Some(FromOverseer::Communication { msg }),
+			FromOverseer::Signal(signal) => Some(FromOverseer::Signal(signal)),
 		}
 	}
 
 	fn intercept_outgoing(&self, msg: AllMessages) -> Option<AllMessages> {
+		let msg = match msg {
+			AllMessages::CollatorProtocol(CollatorProtocolMessage::Seconded(
+				relay_parent,
+				statement,
+			)) => {
+				// `parachain::collator-protocol: received an unexpected `CollationSeconded`: unknown statement statement=...`
+				// TODO: Fix this error. We get this on colaltors because `malicious backing` creates a candidate that gets backed/included.
+				// It is harmless for test parachain collators, but it will prevent cumulus based collators to make progress
+				// as they wait for the relay chain to confirm the seconding of the collation.
+				AllMessages::CollatorProtocol(CollatorProtocolMessage::Seconded(
+					relay_parent,
+					statement,
+				))
+			},
+			msg => msg,
+		};
 		Some(msg)
 	}
 }
 
-/// Generates an overseer that exposes bad behavior.
+/// Garbage candidate implementation wrapper which implements `OverseerGen` glue.
-pub(crate) struct SuggestGarbageCandidate;
+pub(crate) struct BackGarbageCandidateWrapper;
 
-impl OverseerGen for SuggestGarbageCandidate {
+impl OverseerGen for BackGarbageCandidateWrapper {
 	fn generate<'a, Spawner, RuntimeClient>(
 		&self,
 		connector: OverseerConnector,
@@ -107,65 +254,23 @@ impl OverseerGen for SuggestGarbageCandidate {
 		RuntimeClient::Api: ParachainHost<Block> + BabeApi<Block> + AuthorityDiscoveryApi<Block>,
 		Spawner: 'static + SpawnNamed + Clone + Unpin,
 	{
-		let spawner = args.spawner.clone();
+		let inner = Inner { map: std::collections::HashMap::new() };
-		let (sink, source) = metered::unbounded();
+		let inner_mut = Arc::new(Mutex::new(inner));
-		let keystore = args.keystore.clone() as SyncCryptoStorePtr;
+		let note_candidate =
+			NoteCandidate { inner: inner_mut.clone(), spawner: args.spawner.clone() };
 
-		let filter = ReplacePoVBytes { queue: sink };
+		let validation_filter = ReplaceValidationResult::new(
+			FakeCandidateValidation::BackingAndApprovalValid,
+			FakeCandidateValidationError::InvalidOutputs,
+			args.spawner.clone(),
+		);
 
-		let keystore2 = keystore.clone();
+		prepared_overseer_builder(args)?
-		let spawner2 = spawner.clone();
+			.replace_candidate_backing(move |cb| InterceptedSubsystem::new(cb, note_candidate))
-
+			.replace_candidate_validation(move |cb| {
-		let result = prepared_overseer_builder(args)?
+				InterceptedSubsystem::new(cb, validation_filter)
-			.replace_candidate_backing(move |cb| {
-				InterceptedSubsystem::new(
-					CandidateBackingSubsystem::new(spawner2, keystore2, cb.params.metrics),
-					filter,
-				)
 			})
 			.build_with_connector(connector)
-			.map_err(|e| e.into());
+			.map_err(|e| e.into())
-
-		launch_processing_task(
-			&spawner,
-			source,
-			move |(mut subsystem_sender, hash, candidate_receipt): (_, Hash, CandidateReceipt)| {
-				let keystore = keystore.clone();
-				async move {
-					gum::info!(
-						target: MALUS,
-						"Replacing seconded candidate pov with something else"
-					);
-
-					let committed_candidate_receipt = CommittedCandidateReceipt {
-						descriptor: candidate_receipt.descriptor.clone(),
-						commitments: CandidateCommitments::default(),
-					};
-
-					let statement = Statement::Seconded(committed_candidate_receipt);
-
-					if let Ok(validator) =
-						util::Validator::new(hash, keystore.clone(), &mut subsystem_sender).await
-					{
-						let signed_statement: Signed<Statement, CompactStatement> = validator
-							.sign(keystore, statement)
-							.await
-							.expect("Signing works. qed")
-							.expect("Something must come out of this. qed");
-
-						subsystem_sender
-							.send_message(StatementDistributionMessage::Share(
-								hash,
-								signed_statement,
-							))
-							.await;
-					} else {
-						gum::info!("We are not a validator. Not siging anything.");
-					}
-				}
-			},
-		);
-
-		result
 	}
 }

polkadot/node/overseer/examples/minimal-example.rs

@@ -33,7 +33,7 @@ use polkadot_overseer::{
 	gen::{FromOverseer, SpawnedSubsystem},
 	AllMessages, HeadSupportsParachains, OverseerSignal, SubsystemError,
 };
-use polkadot_primitives::v2::Hash;
+use polkadot_primitives::v2::{CandidateReceipt, Hash};
 
 struct AlwaysSupportsParachains;
 impl HeadSupportsParachains for AlwaysSupportsParachains {
@@ -73,8 +73,13 @@ impl Subsystem1 {
 			Delay::new(Duration::from_secs(1)).await;
 			let (tx, _) = oneshot::channel();
 
+			let candidate_receipt = CandidateReceipt {
+				descriptor: dummy_candidate_descriptor(dummy_hash()),
+				commitments_hash: Hash::zero(),
+			};
+
 			let msg = CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromChainState(
-				dummy_candidate_descriptor(dummy_hash()),
+				candidate_receipt,
 				PoV { block_data: BlockData(Vec::new()) }.into(),
 				Default::default(),
 				tx,

polkadot/node/overseer/src/tests.rs

@@ -29,8 +29,8 @@ use polkadot_node_subsystem_types::{
 	ActivatedLeaf, LeafStatus,
 };
 use polkadot_primitives::v2::{
-	CandidateHash, CollatorPair, InvalidDisputeStatementKind, ValidDisputeStatementKind,
+	CandidateHash, CandidateReceipt, CollatorPair, InvalidDisputeStatementKind,
-	ValidatorIndex,
+	ValidDisputeStatementKind, ValidatorIndex,
 };
 
 use crate::{
@@ -108,9 +108,14 @@ where
 				let mut c: usize = 0;
 				loop {
 					if c < 10 {
+						let candidate_receipt = CandidateReceipt {
+							descriptor: dummy_candidate_descriptor(dummy_hash()),
+							commitments_hash: Hash::zero(),
+						};
+
 						let (tx, _) = oneshot::channel();
 						ctx.send_message(CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromChainState(
-							dummy_candidate_descriptor(dummy_hash()),
+							candidate_receipt,
 							PoV { block_data: BlockData(Vec::new()) }.into(),
 							Default::default(),
 							tx,
@@ -792,8 +797,13 @@ where
 fn test_candidate_validation_msg() -> CandidateValidationMessage {
 	let (sender, _) = oneshot::channel();
 	let pov = Arc::new(PoV { block_data: BlockData(Vec::new()) });
+	let candidate_receipt = CandidateReceipt {
+		descriptor: dummy_candidate_descriptor(dummy_hash()),
+		commitments_hash: Hash::zero(),
+	};
+
 	CandidateValidationMessage::ValidateFromChainState(
-		dummy_candidate_descriptor(dummy_hash()),
+		candidate_receipt,
 		pov,
 		Duration::default(),
 		sender,

polkadot/node/primitives/src/lib.rs

@@ -236,6 +236,8 @@ pub enum InvalidCandidate {
 	ParaHeadHashMismatch,
 	/// Validation code hash does not match.
 	CodeHashMismatch,
+	/// Validation has generated different candidate commitments.
+	CommitmentsHashMismatch,
 }
 
 /// Result of the validation of the candidate.

polkadot/node/subsystem-types/src/messages.rs

@@ -39,13 +39,13 @@ use polkadot_node_primitives::{
 	SignedFullStatement, ValidationResult,
 };
 use polkadot_primitives::v2::{
-	AuthorityDiscoveryId, BackedCandidate, BlockNumber, CandidateDescriptor, CandidateEvent,
+	AuthorityDiscoveryId, BackedCandidate, BlockNumber, CandidateEvent, CandidateHash,
-	CandidateHash, CandidateIndex, CandidateReceipt, CollatorId, CommittedCandidateReceipt,
+	CandidateIndex, CandidateReceipt, CollatorId, CommittedCandidateReceipt, CoreState, GroupIndex,
-	CoreState, GroupIndex, GroupRotationInfo, Hash, Header as BlockHeader, Id as ParaId,
+	GroupRotationInfo, Hash, Header as BlockHeader, Id as ParaId, InboundDownwardMessage,
-	InboundDownwardMessage, InboundHrmpMessage, MultiDisputeStatementSet, OccupiedCoreAssumption,
+	InboundHrmpMessage, MultiDisputeStatementSet, OccupiedCoreAssumption, PersistedValidationData,
-	PersistedValidationData, PvfCheckStatement, SessionIndex, SessionInfo,
+	PvfCheckStatement, SessionIndex, SessionInfo, SignedAvailabilityBitfield,
-	SignedAvailabilityBitfield, SignedAvailabilityBitfields, ValidationCode, ValidationCodeHash,
+	SignedAvailabilityBitfields, ValidationCode, ValidationCodeHash, ValidatorId, ValidatorIndex,
-	ValidatorId, ValidatorIndex, ValidatorSignature,
+	ValidatorSignature,
 };
 use polkadot_statement_table::v2::Misbehavior;
 use std::{
@@ -126,14 +126,14 @@ pub enum CandidateValidationMessage {
 	///
 	/// This will implicitly attempt to gather the `PersistedValidationData` and `ValidationCode`
 	/// from the runtime API of the chain, based on the `relay_parent`
-	/// of the `CandidateDescriptor`.
+	/// of the `CandidateReceipt`.
 	///
 	/// This will also perform checking of validation outputs against the acceptance criteria.
 	///
 	/// If there is no state available which can provide this data or the core for
 	/// the para is not free at the relay-parent, an error is returned.
 	ValidateFromChainState(
-		CandidateDescriptor,
+		CandidateReceipt,
 		Arc<PoV>,
 		/// Execution timeout
 		Duration,
@@ -151,7 +151,7 @@ pub enum CandidateValidationMessage {
 	ValidateFromExhaustive(
 		PersistedValidationData,
 		ValidationCode,
-		CandidateDescriptor,
+		CandidateReceipt,
 		Arc<PoV>,
 		/// Execution timeout
 		Duration,

polkadot/zombienet_tests/functional/0002-parachains-disputes.toml

@@ -2,8 +2,8 @@
 timeout = 1000
 
 [relaychain.genesis.runtime.runtime_genesis_config.configuration.config]
-  max_validators_per_core = 2
+  max_validators_per_core = 5
-  needed_approvals = 2
+  needed_approvals = 8
 
 [relaychain]
 default_image = "{{ZOMBIENET_INTEGRATION_TEST_IMAGE}}"
@@ -18,20 +18,20 @@ requests = { memory = "2G", cpu = "1" }
   [[relaychain.nodes]]
   image = "{{MALUS_IMAGE}}"
   name = "alice"
-  command = "malus dispute-ancestor"
+  command = "malus dispute-ancestor --fake-validation approval-invalid"
-  args = [ "--alice", "-lparachain=debug" ]
+  args = [ "--alice", " -lparachain=debug,MALUS=trace" ]
 
   [[relaychain.nodes]]
   image = "{{MALUS_IMAGE}}"
   name = "bob"
-  command = "malus dispute-ancestor"
+  command = "malus dispute-ancestor --fake-validation approval-invalid"
-  args = [ "--bob", "-lparachain=debug"]
+  args = [ "--bob", "-lparachain=debug,MALUS=trace"]
   
   [[relaychain.nodes]]
   image = "{{MALUS_IMAGE}}"
   name = "charlie"
-  command = "malus dispute-ancestor"
+  command = "malus dispute-ancestor --fake-validation approval-invalid"
-  args = [ "--charlie", "-lparachain=debug" ]
+  args = [ "--charlie", "-lparachain=debug,MALUS=trace" ]
 
   [[relaychain.nodes]]
   name = "dave"
@@ -53,49 +53,19 @@ requests = { memory = "2G", cpu = "1" }
   name = "two"
   args = [ "--two", "-lparachain=debug"]
 
+{% for id in range(2000,2004) %}
 [[parachains]]
-id = 2000
+id = {{id}}
 addToGenesis = true
-genesis_state_generator = "undying-collator export-genesis-state --pov-size=100000 --pvf-complexity=1"
+genesis_state_generator = "undying-collator export-genesis-state --pov-size={{25000*(id-1999)}} --pvf-complexity={{id - 1999}}"
 
   [parachains.collator]
   image = "{{COL_IMAGE}}"
-  name = "collator01"
+  name = "collator"
   command = "undying-collator"
-  args = ["-lparachain=debug", "--pov-size=100000", "--pvf-complexity=1", "--parachain-id=2000"]
+  args = ["-lparachain=debug", "--pov-size={{25000*(id-1999)}}", "--parachain-id={{id}}", "--pvf-complexity={{id - 1999}}"]
 
-[[parachains]]
+{% endfor %}
-id = 2001
-addToGenesis = true
-genesis_state_generator = "undying-collator export-genesis-state --pov-size=100000 --pvf-complexity=2"
-
-  [parachains.collator]
-  image = "{{COL_IMAGE}}"
-  name = "collator02"
-  command = "undying-collator"
-  args = ["-lparachain=debug", "--pov-size=100000", "--parachain-id=2001", "--pvf-complexity=2"]
-
-[[parachains]]
-id = 2002
-addToGenesis = true
-genesis_state_generator = "undying-collator export-genesis-state --pov-size=100000 --pvf-complexity=10"
-
-  [parachains.collator]
-  image = "{{COL_IMAGE}}"
-  name = "collator03"
-  command = "undying-collator"
-  args = ["-lparachain=debug", "--pov-size=100000", "--parachain-id=2002", "--pvf-complexity=10"]
-
-[[parachains]]
-id = 2003
-addToGenesis = true
-genesis_state_generator = "undying-collator export-genesis-state --pov-size=20000 --pvf-complexity=1000"
-
-  [parachains.collator]
-  image = "{{COL_IMAGE}}"
-  name = "collator04"
-  command = "undying-collator"
-  args = ["-lparachain=debug", "--pov-size=20000", "--parachain-id=2003", "--pvf-complexity=1000"]
 
 [types.Header]
 number = "u64"